Private defined benefit (DB) plans could represent an expanding market opportunity for advisors, according to Cerulli Associates.
The new sweet spot appears when people “separate” from their traditional employer-based pension plans, the Boston researcher indicated.
Many of those “separated participants” will be looking for a new home for the assets they will take out of the old plan. Advisors having the expertise to help reposition those assets could be looking at an influx of new business.
It can mean some serious business. “The number of separated participants in private DB plans totaled more than 12.4 million at the end of 2011, up from 10 million in 2004,” pointed out Kevin Chisholm, associate director at Cerulli.
Furthermore, over the past year, there has been a steady increase in the number of lump-sum distributions taken from DB plans, “and we expect that number to continue to increase,” he said.
When plans offer separated participants the option of taking distribution as a monthly payout (annuity) or a lump-sum, most will likely select the lump-sum, Chisholm said.
If they do, that’s when the sweet spot opens up. “Lump-sum distributions put a significant amount of assets in motion,” he explained.
“DB plan sponsors could offer lump-sums to participants that amount to larger payouts, which create a new pool of prospects for financial advisors, or an infusion of cash to advisors whose current clients accept the one-time payment.”
The period when the offer is active provides opportunity as well – to help clients decide whether to take the offer or not.
Then there is helping the client after the decision. These participants are not retired, the Cerulli researchers pointed out. Rather, the participants are separated from their former DB plan but likely to still be working and contributing to a defined contribution plan. This will yield additional rollover dollars in the future, the Cerulli researchers predicted.
Another researcher, Aon Hewitt, also sees lump-sum distribution activity heating up. A few weeks ago, the human resources consulting firm reported that 39 percent of DB plan sponsors it surveyed are “somewhat or very likely” to offer terminated vested participants and/or retirees a lump-sum payout during a specified period (a “window”) in 2013.
That’s up from 7 percent of DB plan sponsors that added a lump-sum window in 2012, Aon Hewitt said.
“There is no question that employers are looking for new ways to aggressively manage their pension volatility,” said Rob Austin in a statement. He is a senior retirement consultant of Aon Hewitt.
Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation (PBGC) premiums will begin to increase in 2013 and 2014, Austin pointed out. That will increase the carrying cost of pension liabilities, he said. That, in turn, will give plan sponsors “an economic incentive to transfer those liabilities off their balance sheet.”
In 2012, new rules went into effect that made lump-sum distribution offers a financially attractive option for some employers. The rules derive from provisions in the Pension Protection Act (PPA) of 2006. Among other things, the rules permit amendments to plans to allow full lump-sum distributions on a favorable interest rate basis.
The numbers reported by Cerulli and Aon Hewitt suggest that employers are, in fact, taking advantage of the change. Headlines from last year support that conclusion, too. For instance, big auto makers General Motors and Ford made news when they came out with lump-sum distribution offers to retirees.
Some firms, when making the offers, stress that this is a one-time-only offer. So it’s essentially a take it or leave it option for employees.
Take-up of the offers can make a financial difference to the employer. Consider Kaydon Corp., a firm that designs and manufactures custom engineered products for various industries. It made such an offer in third quarter of last year.
“The company offered certain former non-retiree employees with vested pension benefits the option of receiving a lump-sum payment or an immediate annuity in settlement of all future pension obligations,” the company wrote in its year-end report. “This de-risking of our pension obligations reduced future pension liabilities by $9.2 million.”
If plans do not offer a lump-sum distribution option, separated workers will still receive distributions – as the traditional monthly annuity payouts. This, too, presents opportunity for advisors, in the sense that they can counsel clients on how to manage the clients’ other assets as advisors have done for years.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) defines a lump-sum distribution as the “distribution or payment, within a single tax year, of a plan participant’s entire balance from all of the employer’s qualified pension, profit-sharing, or stock bonus plans.” Participants can roll over all or part of the distribution, with no tax due on the part rolled over, the IRS said. Any part not rolled over is reportable as ordinary income.